2001 Long Island at Charles William Post (N) 13, West Chester (S) 9
2002 @West Chester (S) 11, Stonehill (N) 6 at West Chester, West Chester Pennsylvania
2003 @Stonehill (N) 9, Longwood (S) 8 at Stonehill, Easton, Massachusetts
2004 Adelphi (N) 12, West Chester (S) 11 at Orlando, Florida
2005 Stonehill (N) (21-0)13, West Chester (S) 10
2006 Adelphi (N) 16, West Chester (S) 8
2007 Long Island at Charles William Post (N) (17-0) 15, West Chester (S) 7
2008 West Chester (S) 13, Long Island at Charles William Post (N) 12 at Houston, Texas
2009 Adelphi (N) 16, Lock Haven (S) 4 at Salem Virginia
2010 Adelphi (N) 17, West Chester (S) 7 at Gettysburg, Pennsylvania
2001 North: Long Island at Charles William Post 11, Stonehill 10 (OT)
South: West Chester 17, Gannon 15
2002 at West Chester, West Chester, Pennsylvania
North: Stonehill 14, Long Island at Charles Willima Post 13
South: @West Chester 12, Longwood 11
2003 at Stonehill, Easton, Massachusetts
North: @Stonehill 14, Long Island at Charles William Post 13
South: Longwood 13, Bloomsburg 9
2004 at Orlando, Florida
North: Adelphi 11, @Long Island at Charles William Post 10
South: @West Chester 23, Limestone 12
2005 North: @Stonehill 16, Adelphi 10
South: @West Chester 20, Lock Haven 7
2006 North: 2. Adelphi 9, 1. Long Island at Charles William Post 8
South: 2. West Chester 10, 1. Limestone 8
2007 North: 1. Long Island at Charles William Post 11, 2. Stonehill 8
South: 1. West Chester 16, 2. Loch Haven 14
2008 at Houston, Texas
North: 2. Long Island at Charles William Post 9, 1. Adelphi 4
South: 2. West Chester 17, 1. Limestone 9
2009 at Salem, Virginia
North: 1. Adelphia 15, 2. Long Island at Charles William Post 10
South: 2. Lock Haven 13, 1. Limestone 12
2010 at Gettysburg, Pennsylvania
North: 2. Adelphi 14, 1. Long Island at Charles William Post 9
South: 2. West Chester 9, 1. Lock Haven 8 (OT)
2009 North: @2. Long Island at Charles William Post 16, 3. New Haven 7
South: @2. Lock Haven 17, 3. Mercyhurst 11
2010 North: @2. Adelphi 15, 3. Stonehill 10
South: @2. West Chester 12, 3. Limestone 11